Return to Archives
Return to Article Summaries
October 2006, Vol. 5 Issue 9
|
AN INTRODUCTION TO PODCASTING
by George Lorenzo, Editor and Publisher
"Podcasting" is the word most frequently used by
educators today when writing about or discussing the
evolution of digital audio. This is an obvious outgrowth of
Apple Computer’s 2001 launch of its iPod products and the
iTunes web-based tool and subscription service. While iPod
usage has become pervasive among students today, there are
plenty of other hand-held audio devices and related audio
software that are viable alternatives to the iPod.
The Jacuzzi of Hand-Held Digital Audio Devices
Similar to the word "Jacuzzi," which is really a
brand-name that has come to mean any hot-water tub with
pulsating jets, podcasting has come to mean anything related
to creating and publishing digital audio files online that
can be transferred to a hand-held device.
Shopping for the right tools to create and listen to
podcasts can give you a headache. Learning about what kind
of hardware and software you should have if you want to
create and publish high quality podcasts can give you an
even bigger headache. Regardless, podcasting for educational
purposes is alive and well primarily because this technology
has greatly reduced the cost to produce high quality audio
presentations and make them ubiquitous online.
"Although a picture is worth a thousand words, audio is
an incredible, powerful tool now with ease of production and
ease of dissemination," says John Ittelson, audio expert and
professor of telecommunications, multi-media, & applied
computing at California State University Monterey Bay.
"Audio is obviously a very effective way to convey
information. For example, it lets you display emotions
better than the written word."
Short Reading List
If you’re thinking about adding some form of podcasting
to your courses, you can start with the following suggested
short reading list:
Gardner Campbell,
"There’s Something in the Air: Podcasting in Education," EDUCAUSE Review, November/December
2005 - Campbell sets the stage with a fictitious female student
starting out her day by listening to a variety of course
audio feeds (lectures, excerpts from assigned readings,
group presentations from various assignments, etc.) through
an iTunes interface on her laptop in her room. As she gets
ready for a typical day on any college campus, she quickly
and easily downloads a number of important education-related
audio feeds to her iPod that she can carry with her and
listen to (with ear buds that do not block out ambient
sound) while walking between classes.
Campbell explains that while streaming audio is really
nothing new in the history of the World Wide Web, what makes
podcasting so compelling is how relatively easy podcasts can
be made, published, and accessed on the go. Still, there are
some basic technical issues that podcasters should be aware
of, including "sampling rates (higher is usually better),
compression formats (the major players are MP3, windows
Media Audio or WMA, and Apple’s Advanced Audio Coding or AAC),
and compression bitrates (higher is usually better)." He
adds that, when creating podcasts, "for the sake of elegance
and good bandwidth stewardship, it’s good to try to hit the
sweet spot where moderate file size meets pleasing audio
quality."
Overall, Campbell provides a thorough overview on
podcasting with links to a wide variety of resources in this
must-read, extremely well-written, easy-to-understand and
entertaining EDUCAUSE piece.
Sarah Brittain, Pietrek Glowacki, Jared Van Ittersum,
and Lynn Johnson, "Podcasting Lectures: Formative Evaluation
Strategies Helped Identify a Solution to a Learning
Dilemma," EDUCAUSE Quarterly, Number 3, 2006
- This is a case study from the University of Michigan
School of Dentistry’s Office of Dental Informatics. With the
help of instructional design and formative evaluation
strategies, the Informatics folks conducted three pilots and
came to the conclusion that podcasting audio lectures proved
to be a better solution than creating video recordings
(which were what students in the School of Dentistry were
initially requesting). An enthusiastic group of students,
faculty and educational technologists moved this project
forward, ultimately coming up with sound technical
strategies and a solution to a concern over lecturers’
intellectual property rights, which is a common problem
associated with podcasting.
Peter Meng,
"Podcasting & Vodcasting: Definitions,
Discussions & Implications,"
University of Missouri, March
2005, - This is a straight-forward, concise white paper that
outlines, in general, the processes, tools, equipment,
required skills, and implications of podcasting and
vodcasting (video broadcasts for playing on a mobile
hand-held device). The implications section covers potential
uses, effects on infrastructures, pedagogical concerns, and
a brief note about the future evolution of these
technologies.
University of Minnesota, Office of Information
Technology, Digital Media Center,
"Podcasting in Education,"
February 2006
- A three-page document that is
an ideal, well-written and succinct hand-out that defines
podcasting, covers potential uses and issues and offers
links to some sound resources.
Wikipedia: Although I am generally distrustful of
anything on Wikipedia, it can be a good starting point.
Several authors, including Campbell, suggest reading about
the history of podcasting at
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Podcast.
Some Examples and Advice:
Brandeis University
"The iPod Experience at Brandeis University"
is the title of a website and digital audio initiative that
was produced by the Brandeis Instructional Technology
Resource Center, a division of Library and Technology
Services (LTS). LTS is a collaboration between academic
librarians and information technologists that was started in
2005 with an optimistic vision "to create a rich environment
of people, technology, information, and facilities that
serves learning, teaching, and scholarship and that provides
high quality, accessible, and reliable systems to support
operational decision-making, planning, and analysis."
Although a relatively small and new initiative, the iPod
Experience easily fits under the "rich environment"
category. Started during Spring 2005, this digital audio
project had its roots in a quick, one-month pilot where
students from an anthropology course (Tradition and the
Contemporary Experience in Sub-Saharan Africa with Professor
Mark Auslander) recorded their impressions of a Brandeis
University Women’s Studies Research Center exhibition that
featured "Body Map" paintings created by a group of
HIV-positive women in South Africa. The students recorded
their short impressions (under three minutes) in the
Instructional Technology Resource Center using the Center’s
recording equipment along with
Audacity,
which is a free, open-source software for recording and
editing sounds. These edited audio files were then posted to
a blog as well as pushed out to an RSS feed that was created
by
Feedburner,
a web-based feed management provider used by bloggers,
podcasters and commercial publishers. A podcast
receiver/media aggregator program, called
Juice (similar to iTunes),
was used to receive the feed/audio files and allow students
to select and download them to their computer as well as
load them to an iPod or other digital media player.
The Body Maps project led to a Fall 2005 podcasting
initiative in another anthropology course with Auslander,
titled "Museums and Public Memory." This time the goal was
to record remotely using iPods with Griffin iTalk Voice
Recorder attachments (now obsolete) that were purchased by
and housed in the Instructional Technology Resource Center.
Students borrowed the iPods with iTalk and interviewed
residents and historians from a neighborhood in West
Medford, Massachusetts, which has one of the oldest
Afro-American communities in the United States. These
recordings, along with student commentaries, were developed
into a podcasted walking tour of this historic neighborhood.
There are a number of other iPod projects happening at
Brandeis, but the overall adoption of podcasting for
educational purposes has been small. "I’m not sure if it
(educational podcasting) will grow," says Brandeis
Technology Specialist Janet Hill. "iPods are only one
thing," she adds, referring to the growing popularity of
wikis and the increasing use of camera phones by students on
campus. Hill says that wikis and the latest in cell phone
technologies can be used together creatively for educational
purposes that might peak the interests of today’s Net
Generation.
Which Recording Devices Work Best?
Nonetheless, the Instructional Technology Resource Center
staff is looking at beefing up their digital audio recording
services based on the lessons they have learned in the
podcasting realm. "We are looking at providing some
different devices to other folks on campus interested in
recording," says Hill. "Faculty want to do field recordings
and interviews, and the iTalk did not record at the best
quality. So we are looking at some other digital recording
devices that may record better."
"The limitation we had before was with the iPod itself
(it was not a 5th generation video iPod nor did it have the
optimal microphone and recording adapter - more on this
later)," says Brandeis Technology Specialist Todd Hartigan.
"It works well if you are doing notes to yourself; you can
hear it, you can understand it; it is great for
down-and-dirty recording. But I guess I am more of a purist,
so I will say that you can get better results." The iPod
currently used by Brandeis records only at 16 bit and an 8
kilohertz (kHz) sampling rate (relates to what a microphone
captures). Hartigan recommends recording at a 16 bit, 44.1
kHz sampling rate, which is CD sound quality.
Olympus Alternative
To meet this requirement economically and effectively,
Hartigan suggests the
Olympus WS-310M Voice Recorder,
which retails for $129. The WS-310M has a built-in stereo
microphone and plugs into any USB port for fast file
transfers. It captures Windows Media Audio (WMA) files that
would have to be converted to WAV files in order to play on iTunes and on the iPod itself. To convert WMA to WAV, and
many other formats, Hartigan suggests using Swift sound file
conversion software from
NCH Swift Sound, a company
headquartered in Canberra, Australia.
Cost is only $19.40.
For the iPod Purist
For those who would prefer to use a video iPod with an
adapter for recording, Ittelson recommends the new fifth
generation video iPod with a
Belkin TuneTalk Stereo device,
which features two high-quality omnidirectional microphones.
(TuneTalk does not work with an iPod Nano, and, as far as I
know, there is not a recording adapter on the market for the
Nano.) The new video iPod costs $249 for the 30GB model and
$349 for the 80GB model; the TuneTalk recording device,
which is very compact and plugs into the bottom of the video
iPod, costs $69.99. The omnidirectional functionality is
great for editing purposes. For example, the interviewer’s
questions could be on one track, while the interviewees’
answers could be on another track.
Another relatively new recording adapter for the iPod is
the MicroMemo high fidelity digital audio recorder ($59.95) that
comes from
XtremeMac,
headquartered in Weston, Florida.
For the Ultimate in High Fidelity Recording
Both the TuneTalk and MicroMemo have a plug in that
accepts any 3.55 mm plug microphone. This functionality can
apply to those circumstances where the preservation of high
fidelity sound is vitally important, such as when educators
and students go out into the field to record oral histories
or nature sounds that become part of a rich series of
resources, like an important, historical library collection.
For important interview-related projects, Ittelson
recommends using a Lavalier microphone. Lavaliers are those
small microphones that can be clipped onto a lapel, and they
screen out ambient sound. (I saw Lavaliers online with a
price range starting at about $99 up to $300.) For recording
nature sounds, such as birds and frogs, Ittelson recommends
a parabolic or shotgun microphone that can pick up sounds
from a relatively far distance. A pair of headphones would
also be required, so the person recording nature could hear
what’s being recorded, as well as aim his or her recording
devices accordingly. Parabolics and/or shotguns can range
anywhere from $60 to $2,000, says Ittelson.
Back in the 1970s, the cost of equipment for conducting
such nature recordings was in the $5,000 to $10,000 range
(in 70s dollars), and a backpack was needed to carry it all
around. "Now I can carry everything in my pocket," Ittelson
adds, referring to an iPod with TuneTalk and a high-end
microphone solution. "It provides stereo; it provides high
quality audio; it provides convenience; and it provides a
direct connection with the most popular tool for media
creation today - the iTunes player."
Finally for a great resource on all things related to our
new world of digital audio, in general, Ittelson points to
www.transom.org,
a non-profit organization administered by Atlantic Public
Media. Its mission is "to serve public broadcasting through
training and mentorship, and through support for creative
and experimental approaches to program production and
distribution." |
Return to Archives
Return to Article Summaries
Copyright. All rights reserved. Lorenzo Associates, Inc., P.O. Box 74, Clarence
Center, NY 14032. |