|
MODELS OF EFFECTIVE ONLINE ACCESS
The word "access" in relation
to online learning is typically linked to the
practice of providing the appropriate means and
measures for people with disabilities to
effectively connect to the electronic learning
process. For online learning consultant John
Sener, "access" takes on wider implications.
"Access is much bigger than disability issues,"
he says. "It is an issue that permeates almost
every aspect of the online learning enterprise."
Sener’s presentation at the
recent Sloan-C workshop, titled "Improving
Access to Online Learning: Current Issues,
Practices and Directions," was a comprehensive
overview of this wider definition of access.
Sener presented some
representative examples of effective
access-related practices, excluding disability
issues, and he discussed some future issues
concerning access.
Sener explains that "with a
couple of notable exceptions, the most important
aspects of a student’s experience relative to
access" are built around five key categories:
program access, course access, academic and
administrative services, technical
infrastructure, and learning resources.
Program Access
"Program access refers to accessing
individual degree, certificate, or certification
programs at the institutional level." Some
examples of strategies for improving program
access and "reaching learners in new and better
ways," include partnering with professional
organizations and offering online courses during
the summer months to maintain consistent
connections with students. Another example
stresses reaching new student populations by
developing, and ultimately launching, additional
online programs centered around an institution’s
historic strengths. Additionally, "doing the
basics well, such as providing basic information
(about degree programs offered) with a minimum
of barriers," is an important strategy, says
Sener, who points to the Penn State World
Campus, as a model of an institution with an
effective online learning website that provides
easy-to-navigate and substantial information to
students. He also refers to the University of
Maryland University College, as an institution
that has an effective advertising, marketing and
public relations campaign to inform prospective
students about online learning, especially in
the Washington, DC metro area.
Course Access
"The most basic course access issue is
providing accurate and complete course
information to current and prospective
students," says Sener. Surprisingly, many
institutions offering online learning classes
have not mastered this simple access issue,
which entails providing detailed course
information online to both prospective and
currently enrolled students. Sener points to the
Northern Virginia Community College Extended
Learning Institute as a model institution that
provides "a fairly comprehensive view of a
course online before you actually take a course.
You can look at the objectives of the course and
get everything up front," including complete
course syllabi, guides and policies and
procedures.
Sener also explains that effective course
access also means providing easy and improved
access to a course once a student is actually
enrolled. For example, the overuse of plug-ins
inside an online course, such as the variety of
multi-media players, can cause confusion for
students. One way of eliminating the overuse of
plug-ins is being accomplished at the University
of Illinois-Springfield through the utilization
of a software product called Impatica, which
converts Powerpoint lectures to digital format
with narration, animation and interactive
capabilities, and cuts down on student
frustration with plug-ins.
Academic and Administrative Services
Sener says the area of administrative
services "is advancing fairly rapidly, becoming
more comprehensive as more institutions become
more proficient in practice." He mentions, among
other institutions, Rio Salado’s "Systems
Approach to Online Learning," which is outlined
at the Sloan-C website and also within a Pew
Learning and Technology Program study titled
"Innovation in Online Learning: Moving Beyond No
Significant Difference" by Carol Twigg.
Technical Infrastructure
"Institutions are confronted with a variety
of access-related issues, such as server and
portal reliability and other technical support
functions," says Sener, adding that the
University of South Queensland (USQ) is a leader
in this area through its e-University project.
"Key elements of the project include
incorporating the use of automated response
systems and intelligent databases in the context
of Internet-based delivery. This project will
enable USQ to use technology to automate certain
aspects of interaction with students, increasing
access to higher education on a global scale."
Access to Learning Resources
Providing access to resources that facilitate
learning success is a broad topic that
encompasses many facets of online learning. When
he discusses the topic of learning resources,
Sener mentions the facilitation of interaction
between faculty and learners, the formation of
learning communities, the availability of
support content, the emerging area of
learning-assessment tools, and the issue of what
he calls "learner-centered access."
In relation to both learning assessment tools
and learner-centered access, he provides
examples of self-assessment resources from an
Ohio State University Introductory Statistics
Course that offers a "wide array of learning
options," including one where "students complete
learning-style and student-skills assessments
which they can use to build online course
contracts that specify how they plan to complete
their coursework." Another self-assessment
resource is used by Stanford University inside "courselets"
that "offer self-tests to enable students to
assess their level of knowledge on an ongoing
basis."
Sener adds that "a lot of what online
learning is about is what would happen if you
made it so the learner could choose when and
what he or she wants to study? The philosophy
behind it is rather radical because it says, in
effect, that the students get a lot more say, or
at least as much say, in determining what it is
that they learn."
A question that arises under such
circumstances is how are learning outcomes
presumed to be achieved in any given class?
Should the methods for achieving learning
outcomes be stipulated by the faculty and
institution down to the letter? Or, should the
student decide how learning outcomes are met?
"As learners become adept at this, they should
have more choices," says Sener, pointing to the
Ohio State University example. "However, it is
not all about the learner; it is about the
learning process. There is always a balance to
be negotiated. And the balance depends in part
on the various skills and attributes of the
learning participants involved."
The Future
"Improved access in rural areas is
particularly needed," says Sener, in relation to
the future of online learning. High speed
Internet connections, although growing, are
still far from being ubiquitous across the
country.
Sener also explains that the growth of new
and cheaper electronic devices, such as the
wealth of PDAs now available and new mobile
technology, could have a significant impact on
where and how people access online learning. At
Helsinki University, for instance, a project
called "UniWrap" is looking at mobile
technology’s pedagogical applications.
Overall, Sener concludes that access is
really an issue that is both expansive and
foundational. "There is almost no aspect of the
educational online learning enterprise that does
not have an access-related issue. Access is sort
of everywhere; it is inherent in all of this
because if they can’t get to it; if students
can’t access online learning at some level, then
it does not mean anything, and it can’t be
effective."
As a fundamental issue, Sener says "enabling
prospective learners to be aware of the learning
opportunities available to them and to assess
the potential worth of these opportunities" is
of the utmost importance.
Related Websites:
Sloan-C Effective
Practices Regarding Access
Impatica digital
conversion software
Rio Salado’s systems
approach
University of South
Queensland’s E-University Project
Also see "Fifth
Generation of Distance Education" by Professor
James Taylor
Stanford’s "courselets"
|